Philosophical Theoretical Foundation

4. The Issue of Subordination of Experience: The Development of Non-Human-Centrism

Compared to these theories, a new object theory may offer a better framework for analyzing generative design. Speculative realism lays the groundwork for a cognitive shift in design regarding the concept of "things." Its ontology posits that humans can only perceive the world through their consciousness, while the world exists independently of human consciousness possessing an "absolute reality" beyond human experience (i.e., entities unaffected by human awareness).

This theory emphasizes the independence and diversity of objects, arguing that things exist not only within human subjective intentions but also in complex forms beyond human understanding. It seeks to reinterpret the relationship between matter, reality, and human experience, transcending traditional materialism and idealism.

Representative scholars and their views include:

Scientific knowledge is limited, while object ontology leans toward "unverified true beliefs" through aesthetics. Objects are inherently non-relational. At the observational level, nothing in the world is called a "hammer". It is an epistemological bubble, not a hidden causal agent.

In essence, speculative realism or new materialism serves as the theoretical foundation for speculative design methods in Anglo-American design circles. However, we believed that Harman's explanation has limitations. His "wine connoisseur" analogy reduces intelligence to an analytical device, yet counterexamples exist (e.g., some individuals may be limited to analysis due to profession).